logo-ivar
logo
background

Place-based funding

Terminology arrow""

icon

Terminology


Place-based approaches:

We use the term to mean targeted investment in defined geographic areas. This is usually a package of support – for example: multiple grants; particularly large investments; grants and additional funding plus activity (capacity building, networking, influencing activity) – within a defined place.

We have chosen to explore place-based funding approaches because of:

  • Growing recognition amongst funders that the issues they wish to address – particularly in the most disadvantaged areas – are multi-faceted, and that place-based approaches might be one way of delivering more holistic support.

  • Wider debates and discussion about the role of independent funding in light of policy shifts and the economy, for example reductions in statutory funding, welfare changes and a move towards devolution/localism and away from EU membership.

Place based funding - SMALL
Place based funding - SMALL
Place based funding

1/3

Developing a framework for action

In 2015, we undertook a study of place-based approaches. The research aimed to shed light on the place-based approaches used by UK trusts and foundations and identify learning about the pitfalls and successes of these approaches. Out of this, and other work around place, we have developed a framework for place-based approaches to support funders in their planning and implementation.

Place based funding

2/3

Who is it for?

 

Staff and trustees at charitable trusts and foundations who have responsibility for making strategic decisions about funding approaches or who are leading the delivery of a place-based programme. Community foundations and local funders may also find the framework useful.

Place based funding

3/3

What is it for?

 

The framework is simply a way of organising a conversation when planning or reviewing place-based work in order to: 

 

  • Help surface assumptions and different opinions when working with multiple partners

  • Provide a structure or checklist for use when planning an approach or reflecting on progress

  • Support the sharing of thinking and improving transparency

 

The purpose is not to identify good or bad practice but rather to provide a prompt for discussions, helping funders to consider key questions about place-based approaches

Useful resources

Page source arrow""

icon

Page source

This page and the Working in Place publications are based on:

  • A literature review of place-based approaches in the UK 
  • Interviews with 50+ staff, trustees and partners at 21 UK trusts and foundations
  • Share & Build sessions with 70+ representatives of trusts, foundations and statutory funders at events organised with: ACF and ACF Northern Ireland; the Scottish Funder Forum; Yorkshire Grant Makers Forum; Wales Funder Forum; and London Funders.

background

Download the full report & short framework summary to support thinking & discussion around funding in defined geographical areas.

Front cover image for Working in Place

Research reports:

Working in Place

Eliza Buckley, Ben Cairns, Marilyn Taylor


Download the full, detailed framework for place-based approaches that includes practice examples and funder quotes.

Front cover image for working in place framework summary

Publications:

Working in Place: Framework summary

Eliza Buckley, Marilyn Taylor, Ben Cairns


This short, practical framework can be used to support thinking and discussion around funding in place.

In practice

Story:

Share & build



Senior researcher, Eliza Buckley describes why share and build was a formative part of our approach.

 

After interviewing staff, trustees and partners at trusts and foundations, we analysed the data and arrived at what we thought might be a useful tool – a framework for funders working in place.

We wanted to test and develop the framework to make sure it was as useful as possible. To do this we consulted over 70 representatives of trusts, foundations and statutory funders at events organised with ACF and ACF Northern Ireland; the Scottish Funder Forum; Yorkshire Grant makers Forum; Wales Funder Forum; and London Funders. We shared early research findings and initial ideas for a framework, giving attendees the chance to try it out, adapt it, build it and critique it.

The result – we hope – is a more relevant and practical tool. Some of the conversations we had at these events have also built the case for the next phase of our place-based research – looking at examples of independent and statutory/public funders working together.


background

Scroll down for case studies

Case studies

Lloyds TSB Foundation for Scotland 

Area focus

Lloyds TSB Foundation for Scotland have developed a new asset-based empowerment model to support nine communities in Scotland, which have not previously received funding from independent foundations. 

Activity

Based on interviews and discussion with staff at Lloyds TSB Foundation for Scotland and partners involved in the programme.

Documents reviewed

Lloyds TSB Foundation for Scotland (2015) Briefing paper: Place-based July 2015

 

Lloyds TSB Foundation for Scotland decided to pilot a place-based funding approach as one of their three strategic objectives. They undertook an analysis of where they had previously funded and, in the process, identified some ‘cold spots’. 

Download the case study

The Rank Foundation – Place-based programme in Dundee

Area focus

The Rank Foundations place-based programme runs alongside responsive grant making. This approach used in five places over the last decade. Each time the approach evolves/develop. Consistent features include grants to local projects plus some capacity building and convening activity.

Activity 

Based on interviews with Rank Foundation staff and trustees, the local coordinator in Dundee and a review of programme documents/materials.

 

Learning so far

 

  • Works best in areas that have some existing capacity
  • Requires commitment and realism about what the eventual contribution might be
  • Valuable to have a coordinator who is local, well networked and respected
  • Fine balance between being directive/setting conditions and allowing groups to engage as suits them

Download the case study

Hackney Giving – Placed-based working in east London

Area focus

Hackney Giving provides grants to small, grassroots projects that directly benefit the residents of Hackney in relation to employment and training, or health and wellbeing.

Local leads

Hackney CVS and the East End Community Foundation (ECCF), with a range of other partners on the steering group.

Activity

  • Interviews with staff and trustees at Hackney CVS and East End Community Foundation
  • A review of relevant documents (i.e. Hackney Giving Annual Report 2014) 

Learning so far

  • The importance of shared values 
  • Balancing community needs with the values underpinning the fund 
  • To learn more about how other funders are sourcing funds to support their sustainability. 

 

 

Download the case study

Building Change Trust – Supporting local infrastructure N.Ireland

Area focus

The Building Change Trust was established by the Big Lottery Fund with a National Lottery grant of £10million as an investment for community capacity building and promotion of the voluntary and community sector in Northern Ireland.

Activity

Based on interviews with staff and trustees at Building Change Trust, Big Lottery Fund NI and NICVA, as well as review of Lloyds TSB Foundation for Scotland and East Ayrshire Council, as well as a review of evaluation reports on the initiative.

Learning so far

  • Setting up the endowment
  • Balancing quick wins and longer term strategic development
  • Building relationships and working collaboratively

Download the case study

Participating funders

 

  • Big Lottery Fund 
  • Building Change Trust
  • City Bridge Trust 
  • Comic Relief
  • Community Foundation Tyne & Wear and Northumberland
  • Cripplegate Foundation
  • East End Community Foundation 
  • Esmée Fairbairn Foundation
  • Garfield Weston Foundation
  • Hackney CVS (Hackney Giving)
  • John Lyon’s Charity
  • Joseph Rowntree Foundation
  • Lankelly Chase Foundation
  • Lloyds TSB Scotland
  • Local Trust
  • Quartet Community Foundation
  • The Rank Foundation
  • Sir George Martin Trust
  • Tudor Trust
  • UK Community Foundations
  • Wade’s Charity

 

Attendees of share and build sessions

 

 

  • Association of Charitable Foundations (ACF)
  • ACF Northern Ireland
  • Bank of Scotland Foundation
  • BBC Children in Need
  • Big Lottery Fund
  • Big Lottery Fund Northern Ireland
  • Big Society Capital
  • Brelms Trust
  • Building Change Trust
  • Cardinal Hume Centre
  • Catch 22
  • Cattanach
  • Churches Conservation Trust
  • Comic Relief
  • Community Southwark
  • Cycling Scotland
  • East End Community Foundation
  • Edinburgh & Lothians Health Foundation
  • Faith in Community (Scotland)
  • Foundation Scotland
  • Go For It Fund
  • Hammersmith United Charities
  • Hyde Charitable Trust
  • Inclusion Barnet
  • Inspiring Scotland
  • John Lyon’s Charity
  • Joseph Rowntree Foundation
  • Lankelly Chase
  • London Borough of: Barking and Dagenham, Barnet, Camden and Lewisham
  • Leeds Community Foundation
  • Letchworth Garden City Heritage Foundation
  • Life Changes Trust
  • Lloyds Bank Foundation for England and Wales
  • Lloyds TSB Foundation for Scotland
  • Local Giving
  • London’s Giving
  • Metcalfe Smith Trust
  • Mollie Croysdale Charitable Trust
  • New Philanthropy Capital
  • Oak Philanthropy UK
  • Porticus UK
  • Richard Cloudesley’s Charity
  • Richmond Parish Lands Charity
  • Scottish Government – Third Sector Division
  • Sir George Martin Trust
  • SLOG
  • Social Investment Scotland
  • Spice
  • Sportscotland
  • Wade’s Charity
  • Walcot Foundation
  • West London Zone
  • Wharfedale Foundation

angle-up

Learn more about IVAR